Brewster, NY Criminal Defense Law Firms & Lawyers

The cost depends upon a lot of factors: how much the attorney charges, how aggressive the attorney needs to be, whether the prosecutor is willing to "negotiate", whether the case has to go to an actual trial. Fees could run from, probably $1000.00 on up. Things to consider: the amount/value of the item is irrelevant. The charge is shoplift or theft 3rd degree. This is a gross misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in jail and a $5,000.00 fine. The fact the defendant is 16 years old also does not matter as, I suspect he will be charged into adult court. If this is his first offense, there is a good chance he will not do any jail time; HOWEVER, an attorney could best serve this person by doing what he can to prevent this from being a permanent part of his record (avoiding a conviction). A conviction on his record could be bad news as it will impact his ability to get a job (no one wants to hire someone who steals and cannot be trusted). Additionally, a criminal conviction may impact the colleges he may be able to get into (if that is his goal) and it will disqualify him from being eligible for certain college loans and grants. Bottom line: this is serious. The implications are more far reaching than simply his dealings with the court system. An attorney is going to cost money but if he/she can keep a conviction off his record, it is worth whatever you end up paying.

I would need more information to accurately answer this question.  Generally a conviction can be challenged via a CPL 440 motion.  Was it a plea or a guilty verdict after trial?  When was he sentenced?  However, the grounds are very limited and the motions are usually unsuccessful.  Feel free to call me if you wish to discuss.  

Youthful Offender status is possible and even likely. If you have been arraigned already and you are out on bail,you might avoid jail. If you are re-arrested on any other matter while this one is pending, don't expect to avoid jail. Hire an attorney and let him/her know all the facts and they could advise you better.